How Knowledge On Demand Kind Of Works As A Consultant

Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

I realised I was a consultant before I was a consultant.

“Good work mate,” a colonel once said to me after an intense board room session.

“Huh?” I replied. “What do you mean? I countered the chair’s thoughts and raised more problems. If anything, I feel more like a prick to the course of action.”

“Exactly.”

“I don’t follow,” I said, tilting my head to the right.

“I brought you into the meeting because you would shine a light on things we would have never considered. We needed you to shine a light on what we did not know. I needed you in there to teach us what we have yet to learn.”

As I sit in my uniform and enjoyed my morning reading on Medium, it occurred to the colonel was right. Just because consulting was not in my job description does not mean I was not actively doing it.

In fact, it was more of daily occurrence.

More than I like to admit.

This made me think about the concept that is consulting.

They fly between projects and contracts. They are as knowledgeable as a portable library of lived experience. Their advice dictates a great depth, but they often remain unseen. Shrouded in a sense pragmatism, consultants have become ubiquitous figures in our working world. But who are these mysteries and what exactly do they do?

However, the label “consultant” covers a vast spectrum. The common denominator with consultants is their ability to provide expert advice and solutions.

I’ve indirectly served as an education consultant for my military. I remind others of the differences between education and training. I’ve given briefs on pedagogical practices and learning burnout rate. It’s also quite fun to advise people on the lethal effects of combined fires and learning outcomes.

Photo by Laura Goodsell on Unsplash

Consultants fill knowledge gaps, generate new perspectives and guides clients. It pays to note that those making executive decisions do not want to get it wrong. But they do not know what they don’t know.

That’s where consultants come in.

Though the term seems synonymous with modern jargon, its roots stretch back centuries. The Latin verb “consultare”, means “to deliberate” or “to take counsel.” It’s the journey through languages and historical contexts that unveils the modern consultant (Harper, 2019).

In the 17th century, “consultant” emerged in English. Initially, the word referred to someone seeking advice from an oracle (Oxford English Dictionary, 2023). This early iteration hints at the core function of consultants. Which is to draw upon knowledge and expertise to guide others.

As society progressed, so did the concept.

By the 19th century, “consultant” shifted towards the medical field. It signified a physician called in for specialist advice (OED, 2023). This marked an inflection point, highlighting the engagement and the specialization.

Then, the 20th century happened.

Photo by Susan Q Yin on Unsplash

It was then we witnessed a pivotal expansion of the term. The complexity of businesses fueled the demand for expertise. This lead to the rise of management consulting firms. More often than not, this expertise comes from elsewhere. The iconic Sherlock Holmes story “The Adventure of the Red-headed League” (1893) serves as an interesting start point to this word. The book featured a “consulting detective” who applies his unique investigative skills for hire (Doyle, 1893). Notably, this usage predates the widespread adoption of “consultant” in various industries.

Curious to see how consultants today mirror the same fashion of modality as fiction.

However, the evolution of “consultant” extends beyond mere vocabulary. The 20th and 21st centuries saw the term spread alongside the knowledge economy. Well, the term got more specific. From strategic consultants to IT specialists, the spectrum of expertise broadened. While the core principles of temporary engagement, specialized knowledge, and guidance remained, consultants today are more specific.

The modern consultant operates in a world different from their predecessors. Gone are the days of navigating boardrooms and corporate offices. Today, the consulting industry stretches all over, encompassing a kaleidoscope of areas. After all, all industries want expertise. From digital transformation to non-profit organizations, consultants offer tailored solutions.

The rise of virtual collaboration platforms has further amplified their reach. It allows them to collaborate with clients across geographical boundaries.

While the consulting industry plays a significant role in many sectors, it remains subject to many criticisms.

This necessitates a nuanced exploration.

Financial Concerns and Value Proposition:

• Onerous Fees and Opaque Billing: Top-tier consultancies often command substantial fees. This prompts questions about the return on investment for clients. Concerns center on the potential disparity between costs and benefits. This occurs more frequently when consultancies offer generic solutions. Sometimes only generic solutions are offered. Additionally, a lack of transparency in unclear hourly rates and hidden charges fuel suspicions of overcharging.
• Measuring True Value and ROI: Assessing the true value of a consultant’s work can be difficult. The intangible benefits of expertise and guidance might not translate into quantifiable metrics. This can lead to doubts about the actual impact on the client’s bottom line. This necessitates innovative approaches to value measurement that move beyond mere financial indicators. It also acknowledges the multifaceted nature of consultancy’s impact.

Standardization vs. Customization:

• The Perils of the “One-Size-Fits-All” Approach: Critics argue some consultancies rely heavily on pre-developed frameworks and solutions. This can lead to a lack of tailor-made approaches for specific client needs and contexts. This “cookie-cutter” method risks overlooking crucial cultural nuances. It fails to address unique challenges effectively.
• Cultural Misalignment and Contextual Sensitivity: Applying solutions designed for one industry or culture can be problematic. These include and are not limited to cultural insensitivity and ineffective implementation. Critics emphasize the need for consultants to possess an understanding of the client’s specific circumstance. This will ensure solutions are culturally appropriate and demonstrably relevant.

Accountability and Long-Term Impact:

• Short-Term Engagements and the Accountability Gap: The temporary nature of many consulting engagements raises concerns surrounding accountability. More so for long-term outcomes. If consultants only take part in the initial phases of a project, stakeholders rarely hold them accountable for long-term results. This potential accountability gap demands a more structured long-term approach. This overlooks the long-term consequences and the need for systemic change within the client.
• Revolving Doors and Fragmented Knowledge: This hinders long-term commitment and sustainable change. Fostering stronger client relationships and knowledge-sharing mechanisms can mitigate these concerns. It ensures that the client organization keeps and utilizes valuable insights.

Ethical Considerations and Conflicting Interests:

• Navigating Conflicts of Interest: Potential conflicts of interest arise when consultants have ties to other organizations. This raises concerns about their objectivity and biased recommendations. Robust ethical frameworks and transparent disclosure practices are essential for mitigating these concerns.
• Unethical Practices and Damage to Reputation: Instances of data manipulation, inflated success stories, or misleading advice can severely damage the reputation of the industry.

Impact on Internal Expertise and Employee Morale:

• Over-reliance on External Expertise: Excessive reliance on consultants can create a dangerous dependency. Depending on external knowledge can hinder the development of internal expertise within an organization. This can lead to long-term knowledge gaps and difficulty in solving problems independently. Balancing leveraging external expertise and nurturing internal capabilities must be crucial for any organization.
• Employee Morale and Internal Confidence: The presence of consultants, particularly if perceived as replacing or outperforming internal employees, can negatively impact employee morale. Effective communication strategies and collaborative approaches that leverage both internal and external expertise will foster a fruitful working environment.

Photo by Sebastian Herrmann on Unsplash

By acknowledging and addressing these critical perspectives, the consulting industry can continue to evolve. Ultimately, a willingness to engage and address these criticisms will determine the continued relevance and contributions of consultants.

While critiques of the consulting industry exist, there are also compelling reasons their services remain in demand. Here are some key arguments for the continued relevance and utility of consultants:

Specialized Expertise and Knowledge:

• Bridging Knowledge Gaps: Consultants often possess in-depth knowledge and expertise in specific areas. They fill skill gaps within an organization and tackle complex challenges. This could involve navigating specific technologies, understanding niche industry trends, or implementing a specialized method.
• Fresh Perspectives and Unbiased Insights: Bringing in an external perspective can generate innovative ideas. Furthermore, challenging established thought patterns within an organization can prove fruitful. Consultants, unbound by internal politics or biases, can offer impartial assessments and propose creative solutions.

Objectivity and Transparency:

• Minimizing Bias and Conflict of Interest: Consultants can provide unvarnished reports and uncomfortable recommendations. Often, these are free from internal constraints. This is valuable in sensitive situations, like restructuring, mergers, or performance evaluations.
• Enhanced Transparency and Accountability: When engaging consultants, organizations often demand clear project scopes, deliverables, and performance metrics. This external scrutiny can foster transparency and accountability.

Flexibility and Efficiency:

• Addressing Temporary Needs and Scaling Expertise: Consultants offer a flexible solution for organisations. Often, organisations can achieve this without incurring permanent overhead costs by engaging consultants. This allows organizations to access specialized expertise for limited periods, scaling their workforce as needed.
• Faster Implementation and Streamlined Processes: Experienced consultants can often leverage pre-existing frameworks and methodologies. This speeds up project timelines and implementation compared with developing these capabilities from scratch.

Change Management and Skill Development:

• Facilitating Successful Transformations: Consultants can play a crucial role in guiding organizations through significant changes. This can implement new strategies or overseeing complex transformations. Their experience across different contexts can be invaluable in navigating these transitions.
• Knowledge Transfer and Skills Development: Through collaboration and knowledge-sharing initiatives, consultants can contribute to the skills development of teams. This knowledge transfer ensures the organization keeps valuable expertise even after the consultancy engagement ends.

Hmm. Maybe this is the career change I am curious about.

The decision to engage a consultant requires careful consideration. Recognizing both the limitations and potential value of consultants allows organizations to make informed decisions. Then, they can leverage their expertise to address specific challenges and achieve their goals.

The future of the consulting industry promises to be even more dynamic. Embracing technology, upskilling for niche expertise, and prioritizing client value will be key. As the demand for specialized knowledge continues to rise, the consultant’s role remains more relevant than ever.

I do wonder who consults the consultants.

References

• Doyle, A. C. (1893). The Adventure of the Red-headed League. Strand Magazine.
• Harper, D. (2019). Consultant. Online Etymology Dictionary. Retrieved from https://www.etymonline.com/
• Oxford English Dictionary (OED). (2023). Consultant. Retrieved from https://www.oed.com/dictionary/consulting_n